Police are considering charges of negligence after an 18-month old toddler slipped from her grandfather’s arms and plunged to her death from the 11th floor of a Royal Caribbean ship.
Chloe Wiegand fell 45 metres from a window on Freedom of the Seas onto a concrete pier in San Juan on Sunday afternoon while the vessel was docked. She died shortly after the incident in hospital.
Salvatore Anello reportedly sat his granddaughter on the railing of an open window while the family were in the outdoor dining area on the ship. It is believed he was playing a game when she slipped from his arms and fell out of the window.
The tragic incident is now the subject of extraordinary public scrutiny after lawyers acting for the family claimed the cruise ship could have been at fault and the family issued pictures of the child.
At one stage, it was suggested Mr Anello had lifted the tiny tot out of the window.
But the family’s lawyer hit back, denying the girl was dangled out the window “Michael Jackson style” and claiming blame for the tragedy lay with Royal Caribbean.
Michael Winkleman, acting for the family, maintained Mr Anello placed the child on a railing he believed was behind a glass pane in a part of the ship “designed for kids.”
He told NBC: “There’s a whole wall of windows [on the ship]. The grandfather thought that this window was closed. It turns out, we’ve come to learn, that … passengers can open these windows.
“Unknowingly, the grandfather places Chloe on the wood railing before the wall of windows, believing Chloe will bang on the glass just like she does at her brother’s hockey games. The next thing he knows, she’s gone.
“Why in the world would you leave a window open in an entire glass wall full of windows in a kid’s area?”
Police on Friday said they were investigating all aspects, including the culpability of the cruise line and the behaviour of the grandfather.
Puerto Rico’s Public Security Secretary Elmer Román said “multiple angles” are being looked at in her death, including possible negligence by Royal Caribbean Cruises.
“That is part of the investigation. Once the result is determined, we will report,” Mr Román said, adding that exploring numerous possibilities is “part of the process” in such investigations.
A spokesperson for Royal Caribbean said on Monday: “We are deeply saddened by yesterday’s tragic incident, and our hearts go out to the family. We’ve made our Care Team available to assist the family with any resources they need.
“Out of respect for their privacy, we do not plan to comment further on the incident.”
It is not clear whether Mr Anello or anyone else will be prosecuted. Investigators are reviewing CCTV footage and interviewing passengers before deciding whether to file charges.
Henry Escalera Rivera, Commissioner of the Police Bureau, told Prima Hora: “This is a process that is under investigation.”
Mr Roman told the Primera Hora newspaper just after the incident: “One of the grandfathers, whom it would appear was playing with the little girl, lifted her out of the open window and lost his grip.”
Witnesses told how they heard the family, from Indiana, US, wailing in agony after Chloe fell to her death.
Kimberley Schultz Wiegland posted pictures of herself with her daughter on Facebook. Friends and family left comments like: “Sweet angel. Praying for you and your family Kim.”
Another wrote: “You are loved. Praying for you and your family. I’m so sorry.”
The child’s father is a police officer in Indiana.
Related Posts
-
Royal Caribbean has signalled its intention to build a new cruise port in Juneau, but many city officials claims they were not consulted.
-
Royal Caribbean has delayed its release of Australian itineraries and ship deployments for the 2026/2027 season.
-
Over 100 Australians and other passengers have spent two days trapped aboard their cruise on Spectrum of the Seas in Japan after "maintenance" problems put their cruise on pause A…
-
Mario Salcedo or "Super Mario" has just sailed his 1000th cruise with Royal Caribbean.
How could you not know there was no glass there, have just returned from a cruise and it is so obvious where the glass is and where it’s open air !
This would be a real shame if RC are forced to lock all windows or place bars over every thing . Will they have to lock off all upper deck areas until they put safety nets along the entire length of the ship in case someone leans over too far.
Even if the window was shut the child would have fallen against steel and glass and suffered severe injury!! HE must take responsibility for this unfortunate accident.
It is VERY easy to tell if the large pane of tinted glass is open or shut. The next thing will be you can’t see the ocean unless you look through the bars on the windows because people can’t be trusted not to put children in danger. Or you could insist that every toddler be fitted in a climbing harness and tethered to a responsible adult the entire cruise!
I don’t know the full story but this is a very sad incident and deepest sympathy to the. Family and friends of the toddler.
Sincere condolences to the family and friends keeping you in my prayers. This is a very sad situation for all concerned lm sure no one is really to blame, the staff on these massive ships do a fabulous job keeping every thing ship shape, safe and enjoyable, We all have to take responsibility where ever we trave, Be it ship plane, train or car. Cruising is so safe and l hope people continue to do so.
Maybe the windows should be locked, to prevent a future tragedy? So sad.
Andrew, I agree with your comment on the family’s lawyer.
At a time when they are grieving for the loss of their child I would think it would be last position they would want to be in the public eye like that.
The lawyer must have felt that attack is the best form of defence by accusing the cruise line of negligence and deflecting responsibility away from the grandfather.
In any case it’s a tragic event that will affect the family forever.
How very sad for all involved, but shame on the lawyer Michael Winkleman, just a parasite leeching on the family’s loss.